< Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next >
"Ellen White's Contradictions on Jewelry"
Update: August 16, 2005
After only a week online, we are ready to issue an update to this topic, thanks to further information from
Dirk Anderson. If Dirk's information is reliable, then we now know that the
picture of Ellen White and her sister on Dirk's web site has been doctored twice, not once as we had previously
On July 3, 2005, we sent the first of three enquiries to Dirk, asking for more information about
where he had gotten that picture of Ellen and her sister
Elizabeth from. From July 9 through August 6 we received back four replies, and the only answer we could get
was that he had gotten it from the 2000 edition of Sydney Cleveland's book. Of course, as we have
pointed out, that cannot possibly be true.
We thus felt fairly comfortable posting our analysis on August 7, initially assuming that all the tampering
with that picture had occurred after it had been scanned. However, that assumption was incorrect.
By August 13 Dirk had read our analysis, but not carefully enough to catch everything that we
said. We quote below from his note of that date:
When you asked, I assumed the picture in the copyright 2000
book was the same as the one in prior versions, but it is cropped
slightly. I did get the picture from White-Washed, it was scanned
in by myself. I don't know which exact version it appeared in
uncropped because I gave away all of my older versions. Someone
complained about the poor quality and graniness [sic.] of the picture,
so we smoothed it out and increased the contrast.
You're lying (what's new?) when you say it was doctored because
no object was added or taken away from the picture.
The discerning reader will note:
- The 2000 edition of White-Washed does not contain
a cropped version of a larger picture from an earlier edition. It is instead a copy of an already cropped
picture (see below).
- We aren't lying when we say that the picture Dirk posted on his web site is doctored because:
- in his picture the shade of gray of the "chain" is lighter than the wall when it should be darker than the wall, and
- the pocket watch chain ends at a different place on Ellen White's dress than it did in the original.
- The picture Dirk claims to have innocently altered was in fact already altered by someone else.
This suggests that Dirk never bothered to make sure that the picture he was copying was authentic.
Still unanswered questions include:
- For how long did previous editions of Sydney Cleveland's book contain the bogus picture?
- Did Cleveland tamper with the picture himself, or did he copy yet someone else's picture without verifying its authenticity?
- Has Cleveland or his book's current publisher ever published an apology or retraction for distributing a bogus picture of Ellen White?
Where the Current Picture in White-Washed Came From
Though the 2000 edition of Cleveland's book devotes 26 pages exclusively to the topic of plagiarism,
it gives no hint that Cleveland got the replacement picture in question from a 1960 book entitled, The Spirit
of Prophecy Treasure Chest.
The Treasure Chest picture conclusively proves that the present picture in Cleveland's book is
not a cropped version of his previous, doctored picture. Here are the entire pictures as found in the 2000
edition of Cleveland's
book and in Treasure Chest. Not only do the bottoms of the pictures end at precisely the same point,
but Cleveland's copy faithfully reproduces a defect in the picture from Treasure Chest, marked by
the lower red arrow.
|From Spirit of Prophecy
The upper red arrow points to where Cleveland filled in the circle that was around the "1."
Here's a close up of his fill-in work:
|From Cleveland, Close Up
Cleveland suggests that someone had accused him of dishonesty and fraud in the use of his previous
picture. Just above his present picture he says:
Ellen White's supporters . . . will accuse you with deception rather than accept the photographic
evidence placed in front of their eyes.—White-Washed, p. 203.
After examining the photographic evidence for ourselves, we can understand why:
- Cleveland gives no hint whatsoever that Ellen White was wearing a pocket watch, not ornamental jewelry.
- He gives no evidence to support his claim that that chain was made of gold.
- His previous picture showed a chain that went to Ellen White's side, when her watch was in her front pocket.
- His previous picture showed a chain lighter than her dress, when it was the same shade of gray as her dress in the original photograph.
Dirk's Original Picture
We want to especially thank those who supplied us with the picture Dirk had originally posted on his site
prior to smoothing out the graininess. We present it below:
|Dirk's Old Picture
In this old picture the graininess remains in the dresses and faces, graininess which Dirk later removed.
(Nothing wrong with that.) Thus it appears at present that Dirk did not draw the "gold chain" on the dress.
Who did, whether Cleveland or an earlier critic from whom he got the picture found in his book, we do not
presently have a clue.
We are unprepared to say that every criticism against Ellen White is as unfounded as this one, but an apology
and retraction is definitely in order for the use of this fraudulent picture.
< Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next >